Same-Sex Marriage: A Legal or Moral Issue?

The United States Supreme Court has taken on the task of deciding one of the more far-reaching moral issues of our lifetime. Should same-sex marriage become the law of the land? Whatever their ultimate decision turns out to be, it will shake the foundations of our society.

There is a question that has been largely ignored in this debate – or perhaps marginalized. It is the question: Is this primarily a legal issue or a moral issue? Those on the side supporting same-sex marriage have tried to frame this debate as a legal issue in the courts of our land and an issue of fairness in the courts of public opinion. Those who oppose redefining marriage have largely abdicated the moral argument and tried to argue this case on a legal basis, perhaps because they are afraid of how they will be judged in the court of public opinion.

But make no mistake about it – this is a moral issue that will require a moral judgment.

To say that prohibiting marriage between two people of the same-sex is wrong is a moral judgment. It is also a moral judgment to say that sanctioning marriage between two people of the same-sex is wrong. No matter which way you dice this issue it comes down to a question of morality – not legality. The legal issue will always be undergirded by the moral question. The very concepts of right and wrong presuppose a standard of morality.

Laws by their very nature are based on that standard. Why do we have laws prohibiting murder, polygamy, incest, speeding and a host of other issues? We have them because we believe that those actions are not only harmful to society (another moral judgment) but at their very core they are immoral. As a society we believe that it is not only unsafe to drive 60 mph past an elementary school as children are walking home from school – it is immoral. The argument that we need to keep morality out of this discussion is bogus. You can’t have a law without making moral judgments.

When the Supreme Court announces their decision, they will not only determine the definition of marriage in our country, they will determine the moral direction of our country. And no amount of legal jargon can change the inevitable. Legal decisions do not exist in a vacuum. They determine actions, influence world views and teach the next generation what our society views as right and wrong.

God has made it clear that righteousness is a good thing for nations. Proverbs 14:34 says Righteousness exalts a nation, but sin is a disgrace to any people. The nine members of the Supreme Court, from a secular perspective, are the gatekeepers of the moral culture of our nation. They need to accept the fact that they will determine the moral course that we will follow and make a decision that not only stands up to legal scrutiny but is in the best interest of the moral future of our country.

Stay in the Word
Pastor Steve

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Same-Sex Marriage: A Legal or Moral Issue?

  1. It’s both.

    Legally, gays should be allowed to marry.

    Morally, gays should be allowed to marry.

    • Pastor Steve says:

      True, it is both a legal issue and a moral issue. However, something can only be a moral issue if there is an ultimate standard of right and wrong. Without a standard that is true for all people at all times there is no moral/immoral distinction. Then the issue becomes – Who or what is the standard? That’s a question worth pursuing. For the Christian, God as revealed in the Bible is the standard of what is or is not moral behavior.

      • “However, something can only be a moral issue if there is an ultimate standard of right and wrong.”

        I do not accept this claim, and even if I did, I see no good reason to think that you have that ‘ultimate standard’.

        ” Who or what is the standard? ”

        Harm and benefit.

        Two adult citizens who love each other and decide to get married cause no harm to anyone.

        You can have whatever morality you want. But you can’t force it on others unless you can show that things you think are immoral can cause definitive harm.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s